A category filter can be correct and still be awkward to use. A short row of buttons makes familiar topics easy to spot; a dropdown keeps a longer taxonomy from taking over the page. With Filter Query Block 4, you can change that presentation while keeping the same native WordPress Query Loop and result cards.
This guide uses a taxonomy such as Categories, Tags or a custom topic taxonomy attached to your chosen post type. Taxonomy choice filters work in both editions; Pro’s custom-field filtering is a separate feature. Start with the edition you already have installed and a working feed, rather than rebuilding the Query to try another control.
Choose buttons when the useful choices fit comfortably
Buttons suit a small set of recognizable topics. For a news feed, “All”, “Research”, “Company news” and “Events” let readers see the available routes before making a choice. They also make the selected topic easy to notice beside the results.
Use the actual labels to judge the space. Four long department names can need more room than eight short topics. Preview the narrowest layout you expect visitors to use; if the controls form several crowded rows or hide important choices behind overflow, try a dropdown. There is no fixed term-count threshold that works for every design.
Choose a dropdown when the list needs room to grow
A dropdown suits a longer taxonomy, lengthy labels or a toolbar with several independent filters. Give it a clear label such as “Topic” or “Location” so visitors understand what they will find when they open it. Avoid making every filter look like an unexplained “Select” control.
For a long list, enable Search inside choices. This searches the available option labels inside that dropdown. It does not search post titles, article text or PDF contents, and typing there does not choose a term. Keep a separate Search control when readers also need to search the content entries.
Change the presentation without changing the content source
Open the page in the block editor, select its filter bar and choose Edit Filter Query. Under Filters, select the taxonomy control. In Basic, confirm Filter by still points to the intended taxonomy, then change Presentation to Buttons or Dropdown. Keep the same Query and Post Template while comparing them.
Set a useful Label and check Allow multiple selections. For a dropdown, its Data settings include Search inside choices and Option order. Alphabetical ordering can help readers scan a large list. Show item counts is optional: taxonomy counts describe the initial Query across all its pages, before visitor filtering; they do not promise live counts after every selection.
Choose Apply changes and save the page. If the layout still needs adjustment, use Design for shared appearance or edit the individual blocks. Changing the result-card layout is a separate decision from changing a filter’s presentation.
Decide whether visitors should choose one topic or several
Use single selection when the task is “show me this section”. Keep the unselected “All” choice understandable and include Reset so readers can recover from combined filters. Multiple selection is useful when people need several topics at once, but check the matching rule as well as the visual style.
A post matching any selected term is different from a post that must match every selected term. A dropdown does not decide that rule for you. For example, choosing Research and Events should return the posts your content model intends, whether those choices are displayed as buttons or in a menu. Compare the same selections before and after changing presentation.
Check real results, then check a phone
On a preview, choose a topic with known posts and confirm their titles appear. Combine it with the separate content Search control, try an empty result, then use Reset. Check pagination and a shared filtered URL so the new presentation has not distracted from the complete browsing flow.
For a searchable dropdown, type part of a visible term label, confirm the menu narrows, and select the intended option. Clear the menu search and check that other choices return. On a phone, inspect long labels, selected states and the filter dialog’s Apply and Cancel controls when your design uses a dialog. Test keyboard navigation as well as pointer clicks.
If a choice is missing, check the source first
Switching from buttons to a dropdown does not create terms or assign posts to them. Confirm the taxonomy belongs to the Query’s post type, the expected entries are published, and the control’s available-choice settings include the term. A term with no matches in the initial Query can be hidden; changing its presentation will not make matching posts appear.
Continue with the category-filter setup guide, styling the controls or checking shared links and pagination. Choose the control that keeps your real labels understandable, then verify the same expected results in either presentation.